I just found this which I think proves Catherine is the daughter of George and Rebecca.
From the Jonesboro Gazette 14 Jan 1893: Catherine “Grandma” Albright died 7 Jan 1893, at Springville and was buried in St. John’s Cemetery.
She was the widow of Frederick Albright, a stone mason. She married 1st Mr. Costley and had one son, Jacob Costley of Dongola. By her second husband she had two sons and one daughter. She left one brother, Dan Davault, and two sisters, Mrs. John Fisher and Mrs. Michael Pickett.
I am trying to find the sister that married Michael Pickett which is probably Mary. Also the son, other than George W
This is not my direct line but have many connections.