I've looked in my database and on ancestry.com and cannot locate this Susan Eby. I wonder if she was married before and Eby is her married name? The closest I can come is Susannah Eby b. 1851 to David Eby and Elizabeth Winger who were born in PA and moved to Ohio. However, this Susannah is twice listed in census records as being born in 1851 and the Susan married to William Bergdorf is several times in the census as being born 1857 - 59.