I'm at an impasse and need some help. My grandmother was Lucy Naomi (Edie) LaFontaine. Her father was Asa Howard Edie. Asa Howard Edie's (1877-1954) father was Judson J. Edie (b. abt 1845 in Washington County, NY). It's believed his wife's first name was Margaret (b. 1853). Judson's father was supposedly a William Edie (b. abt 1794) and his wife's name was Lucinda (b. abt 1808). I can find no definitive data on Judson or William. There is another William Edie (b. 1797) who had a son, Judson (b. 1826) and I can't differentiate if this is actually the father of my gggrandfather, Judson. Any help from the Edie clan would be greatly appreciated.