My line is from Indiana as well. My great grandfather Vern Palmer Elijah had a son Herschel and then divorced and moved to Ohio (Hebron Ohio Licking Cty) where he married my great grandmother Cordelia Baker (her second marriage as well) and then they had two daughters: my grandmother Marjorie Elizabeth Elijah and her sister/my great aunt Ethel Lucille Elijah. Herschel Jr. is still alive and on the message boards here and he probably has some info on the Indiana side since it was his father that was still living there when his grandfather divorced and moved. I am so excited to finally find a link I would love to find out where the family originated. I have a photo of Vern and his father and grandfather if you want it I can email it to you.
Tricia trajo37@yahoo.com