I believe you and I are on the same track!! Frances Caldwell d. of W. and Matilda Caldwell was married to Zater Cushing Ellis in Putnam Co. WV. I understood he died. Zater & Fanny had 4 children, Margaret b. 1854, Joseph B. b. 1856, James A. b. 1858 & William H. b. 1861. Fanny also had a sister with the initial M. b. 1849. In the census for Roane Co. 1870 you'll find Fanny remarried to my GGreatgrandfather Josua Hamon. They had 3 children together, Leah, Robert E. Lee and Mary Hamon. Fanny died April 10. 1879. I have been searching for more on her older kids, who I understand helped raise my Greatgrandmother Leah Hamon Sutherland. I have no info as of yet on Zater. You may email me direct if you wish to correspond further! Thanks. Kathy-jo