I would like to start a thread to try and solve the question of who was John Evinger's wife. Let's pool the information that we have and try to solve the puzzle. Please submit only information that is verifiable. Here's what I have:
John Evinger is buried at the Riverside Cemetery in Arkansas City. I have visited his grave. The tombstone says he died March 23, 1893 at age 77. His wife(s) are not buried there.
Jane Eliza Yager Evinger is buried at the DeSota Cemetery in Johnson Co., Kansas. I have not visited, but have a copy of the tombstone extraction which says she was b. Jan 28, 1818 and died Aug. 8, 1883.
According to Jefferson County Virginia-Kentucky Early Marriages Book II June 1826-June 1837 John Evinger and Eliza Jane Yager were married in Jefferson Co., KY May 9, 1836.