So Charles was a cousin? Do you still have the paper? If so, could you email me a copy of what it says?
I have thought for about 2 years now that William and Ann Alltop-Forinash were Nathan Wesley Forinash's parents. Considering that people named their first born after their parents, well Nathan's first born son was named William and his first born daughter was Mary Ann. A few years ago when I first started researching and didn't know to save every tidbit of information to help solve the puzzle, I found a record online that had Ann Alltop listed as Mary Ann Alltop, but I can't find it now. Both William and Ann are the right age to be Nathan's parents, their marriage is a few years before Nathan was born and their location in Virginia and Kentucky are both positives for them being Nathan's parents.
But nothing proof positive has been found yet to make that connection. That's why I was asking about the paper you found in the bible. It just may be the puzzle piece we need.