I understand the confusion. I have had the same confusion over my Thomas Fuller and Lucy Burt. The Thomas Fuller that the Mayflower people seem to identify with Lucy Burt was supposed to have died in 1804 at the age of 82. I am sorry, but my Thomas and Lucy had children born later than that. They did not even get married until 1796 in Richmond Berkshire, MA. Where they came by the logic of the Thomas being 82 marrying a woman 22 is beyond me. My research has been through following the trail of the Fullers and the associated families who were in Warren County, NY and where those families were from. Almost all of it leads back to the Fullers of East Haddam and their connection to the Rowleys married to the Fullers of East Haddam (Thomas Fuller and Martha Rowley). The same Rowley family shows up in Berkshire County and in the Connecticut county just to the south of Richmond. Family after family has connections to Warren County, NY. Even the town of Bolton comes from the town of Bolton in Tolland County, CT. Where Thomas's father, Jehiel is buried. But the Rowleys and the Fullers are connected so many times it is amazing. If I meet a Rowley, I am most likely meeting a cousin.
Eileen Fuller (Edward, John & Mehitable Rowley , Thomas, Thomas & Martha Rowley, Jehiel, Thomas, Lyman, Joel Chester, Chauncey Orson, Theodore Lane and me.