John; I beieve this is my Alex. Gammie. I also have hit a brick wall, the info. in family search is wrong. The birthdates and gravestone inscriptions are not lining up. I believe that Andrew is too old to be Alex.'d dad, Andrew that I have is circa 1660? I'm still looking, but in the meantime maybe you could send me what you have on GAMMIE's and I'll compare it to my notes, and share what I have. My grandfather was John GAMMIE b. 1881 in Marnoch. Thanks, Susan