Believe there was only one Phineas Kimball Garney, no Sr. and Jr. His parents were Lewis Garney and first wife, Elvira Matilda Dow.
Phineas was born July 1849 in Cabot or St. Johnsbury, Caledonia Co., VT.
1850 - Cabot, Caledonia Co. (became Washington Co. in 1855), VT: Phineas Garney, 6/12, w/parents & siblings.
1860 - Cabot, Washington Co., VT: Phineas Garney, 10, w/parents & siblings.
1870 - East Cabot P.O., Cabot, Washington Co., VT: Porter [sic] K. Garney, 20, boarding w/Clark family, works in sawmill.
If Phineas did marry Sara C. Utley, the marriage took place after 1870 and ended before 1880. (Have searched, but can’t find any information about Sara; don’t know where her name came from.)
1880 - Cabot, Washington Co., VT: Phineas Garney, 31, single, servant in home of Orson & Susan Kimball.
March 9, 1881 - Phineas, age 32, married Mary Lomira Marsh.
1900 - Cabot, Washington Co., VT: Phineas Garney, 50; Mary L. Garney, 48; daughter Alice M. Garney, 16; son Clare W. Garney, 7. Mary was listed as mother of 3 children/2 living. So a third child was born and died before 1900, suppose it could have been a son named Phineas Kimball Garney.
1910 - can’t find family.
1920 - Cabot, Washington Co., VT: Phineas K. Garney, 70; Mary L. Garney, 68.