Thank you for the reply. This morning had a 1 hour ($49 charge) call with a DNA expert with Genetree.com and she informed me the same thing. I have also seen the Lucinda Garten with Lewis Copeland and ruled that one out as a possible since mine has a headstone with 1805 and Lucinda Garton Miller. Also census and marriage records for the John Miller/Lucinda line. Just nothing on her parents. I do have some other researchers that have her as Lorinda Lucinda Garton if you come across another Lucinda or Lorinda.