Thanks, Dee! I have since run across this info from "The Atlas of Chautauqua County", 1881:
Elijah Green, a stonemason by trade, and a farmer and dairyman by occupation, was born in Ellington, December 25, 1824. His parents were Ebenezer and Roxanna Green, early settlers. Mr. Green was a fifer at the old militia trainings. In 1855 he married Mary Young, of Ellery, and September 18th, 1865, Jane Stowell, of Stockton. His first wife died about 1863.
Any thoughts on what is more accurate for Elijah's wife Mary - Mary Arnold, daughter of Charles and Keziah Arnold, or Mary Young, daughter of David and Irene Young?