Have noticed your informed replies over the years. I was glad to read this particular one regarding Edwin.
I had Ernest Vince/Vincent Hinchcliff listed with Robert Marion Hinchcliff from census images, and named as grandson.
The rather iffy database of the Family Data Collection lists Ernest as son of Edward, as the poster of the first message indicated. Like you, I had Edwin that married Amanda Jane Keith. So, how did we learn that Ernest Vincent is son of Edwin/Edward? I do not have when Edwin or Amanda Jane died or why their son was with Robert Marion.
Admittedly, there are more than one Vince/Vincent.
I do have the pension papers for Priscilla "Patsy" Hampton Hichcliff Dillard that shows that her son with John Hinchcliff was Robert Phillip Hinchcliff and not Robert Marion Hinchcliff as well. (some databases confuse these two Robert individuals)
I would sincerely appreciate your input. Thank you.