I am from the same line. My Gr-Grandfather was James (Jacky) Hodges son of James H. Hodges and Carlisle Cayton. William Hodges Sr. was one of the first settlers of Rabbit Hash Ky. They even have a huge sign in the center of town listing the first settlers. William is first on the list. Carlisle's parents were Andrew Cayton & Parthena Ryan, like you the info I have is they were from Indiana. Nothing else on the Caytonsor Ryans.