I forgot to say this in my previous post. I'm sure you could do the math yourself, but I will point out that the William born in 1812 would at least be the right timeframe to have been my g-grandfather William Gladstone Hutchinson's grandfather.
William Hutchinson b. 1812
William Hutchinson (could be his son?) born c. 1839
William Gladstone Hutchinson b. January 6 1969 (my g-granfather)
At least we know that part of the equation could work...
If anyone else out there has info or access to info on any of the names Abbey and I have posted, I would be terribly grateful for your contributions. I would especially love to know of anyone who has a connection to William Gladstone Hutchinson's siblings (James, Mary, Thomas or Henry B.) or his cousin (Florence Whalley).