Thank you. Any help will be appreciated. I live in the Midwest, so research in Virginia is pretty unlikely. I am not certain that Sarah's mother was Mildred Dillard; that information came from an online tree so I don't know what the original source was. I had often wondered how Sarah Hutchinson and Robert Lumpkin met, but if William Hutchinson/Hutcheson was his brother's guardian, that might show that there was a long-standing connection between the families. Do you have birth dates for the children of Isaac Lumpkin? Robert was born in either 1776 or 1778. I think 1776 is more likely as he was honored in a centennial celebration in Lancaster, Wisconsin as being 100 years old and the oldest citizen of Grant County, Wisconsin. He died in 1878. Finding ancestry for both Robert and Sarah has been quite difficult.