I don't have any family history, but do have an ancestor John HUTCHINSON who lived in NYC area about that time.
Do you have any idea how old John Hutchinson would have been? My great-grandfather is John Hutchinson who served during the Civil War with first a NY infantry unit and later with a NY cavalry unit.
He returned to NYC area after the war and married a Quaker woman he met in Waterford, Virginia.
I've never been able to connect him to anyone prior to his Civil War service.