I am decended from Levi, Carlton, Keith Koile Line. I submitted a YDNA 25 marker test with family tree DNA. The results were NO matches with anyone in the database. When I say I submitted, it was not my sample it was my fathers sample, it has to be a direct decendant male not female to compare the surname. Also can't be an adopted male. As there hasn't been any indication of any adoption thru the line I can assume that the results are correct for Levi's line.
I went thru the Coil/Kyle group. The ones in the database so far are Kyle from Tyrone Ireland, Valentine Coil from Augusta, Va. and a few other Coil/Kyles that aren't matched as well.
(1)Levi Koile family is the one From Delaware Co, Indiana
1880 Levi G. (sic) is living in Buchana Co. Iowa age 37born Indiana sons Carlton E. age 7 born in Ia., Ralph age 6 born in Iowa, Samuel F. (sic) age 65 born in Ohio. (Has Samuel's parents born in Pa. however a previous census in Indiana has his father John, born in VA.) also 3 daughters and stepson Allen Oakley in the household.
Delware Co. In. George W. Koile age 32 b. IN wife Mary E.age 30 -2daughters. Ths is Levi's brother.
(2)William Koile's family is from Vigo Co. Indiana.
Sullivan Co., Indiana In the household of Abraham DeBaum, Sarah A. Koile Niece. She is decended from William Koile.
Clay Co., IN. C.W. Koile (I believe this is Charles) age 43 born Ohio. wife Lucy A. and son Edgar age 12 IN. (I would have to check previous census to see if he was the one that was adopted)
(3) Marion Co. Indiana shows another koile family Robert Koile born in Scotland age 30, wife Elizabeth age 26 born in England and son Robert age 6 born in New York. They are in the same household as Silas Moore and Charles Williamson and Frank Scott. This might be a boarding house. Robert is listed as an Ice Dealer.
(4) Reynolds Co. Missouri Samuel W. Koile age 30 born PA fathers and mothers birthplace PA. wife Mary C. 2 daughters born in MO and one son John L. age 1 month born in MO.
I dont' know who they decend from.
(5)Spanish Fork Utah Adelinda Lewis age 37 born in Illinois 5 daughters and one son Albert Koile age 13 born in Utah fathers birthplace USA mothers IL.
I think the Utah Koile's maybe using Koyle.
So there could be 5 distinct Koile families unless a connection could be made.
The problem with using Census as indication of surname spellings is that whoever did the census spelled it as they thought it should be spelled not how would be spelled. So variation could be from the census takers own family language or a foreigners accent when giving the info to the census taker.
The information was taken from transcribed census records which could account for some of the mistakes.
the DNA i submitted has atleast excluded some of the Coil/Kyle families as being related. However it doesn't include or exclude the differnt Koile goups as no DNA has been submitted from them for comparison.
Atleast I have a base line for Levi to continue to compare as new DNA submissions are done.