I have a John b. 1843 d. 1898 m. Annie Reeves b. Oct 1861. Their children Susan Deborah b. 26 Nov 1893 in Riverhead and Roswell J b. 28 Feb 1897 d. 25 Sep 1966.
John's dob seems to be the issue. I have no source for my data. It could have been the L'Hommedieu book.