While searching through local census records...found this one.
1860 Columbiana County Ohio Census, Butler Twp.
John McGaffie(c?), age 48 born in PA, he is listed as a master cooper as occupation.
Also in household,
wife Elizabeth age 46 born Ohio.
Son Jefferson age 23 born Ohio, also a master cooper. Daughter Josephine age 18 born Ohio.
Son Robert S. age 16 born Ohio occupation laborer. Daughter Margaret age 14 born Ohio.
Daughter Caroline age 12 born Ohio.
Son John age 10 born Ohio
Daughter Elizabeth age 7 born Ohio
Believe there is an error in the spelling of the name. Daughter Margaret (McGaffick) marries Leander Shriver 4/6/1868 in Columbiana County, and daughter Caroline (McGaffick)marries Jacob Peterson, on 7/22/1869 in Columbiana County, Leander Shriver signed Caroline and Jacob's marriage application. Do these McGafficks match with any of the ones coming from Pa?