Here is my take on the Panther-Gibby lines which are all my ancestors:

1 Daniel Alexander Gibby 1818 - 1889
....+Roinna Rowland 1818 -
.... 2 Ruth Gibby 1841 -
.... 2 James S. Gibby 1843 -
........+Louisa Emmoline Panther 1842 -
........3 Samual Clingman Gibby 1871 - 1938
............+Cinderella (Ella) Smith 1870 - 1941
............4 Chester Clifton Gibby 1914 - 1990
................+Marvel Elizabeth Hill 1917 - 1999
........3 Martha Elizabeth Gibby
............+Alfred Pinkney Panther
............4 Bessie Louella Gibby 1897 - 1989
................+Troy Kenneth Wright
......*2nd Wife of James S. Gibby:
........+Mary Mira Panther-Thomasson 1847 -
.... 2 Jackson R. Gibby 1848 -
.... 2 Martha Gibby 1850 -
.... 2 Geo W. Gibby 1855 -


1 John S. Panther 1816 -
.... +Mary 1822 - 1888
.... 2 Martha Panther 1840 -
.... 2 Louisa Emmoline Panther 1842 -
........+[1] James S. Gibby 1843 -
........3 Samual Clingman Gibby 1871 - 1938
............+Cinderella (Ella) Smith 1870 - 1941
............4 Chester Clifton Gibby 1914 - 1990
................+Marvel Elizabeth Hill 1917 - 1999
........3 Martha Elizabeth Gibby
............+Alfred Pinkney Panther
............4 Bessie Louella Gibby 1897 - 1989
................+Troy Kenneth Wright
.... 2 Samuel Panther 1845 -
.... 2 Mary Mira Panther-Thomasson 1847 -
........+[1] James S. Gibby 1843 -
.... 2 John Panther 1850 -


1 Aurzema Panther
.... +Sarah Boyd
.... 2 Alfred Pinkney Panther
........+Martha Elizabeth Gibby
........3 Bessie Louella Gibby 1897 - 1989
............+Troy Kenneth Wright