I'm looking for information on William P. Plumley who was born in Pennsylvania, August 1836. Census records show there were two William Plumley's born in PA in 1836. One William was born in Salisbury Township, Lancaster County to Lemuel Plumley and Elizabeth Hutton. The other William was born in Middleton Township, Delaware County to John and Mary Plumley. Does anyone have information on these two William's to help me determine which might be my gggrandfather? William P. Plumley moved to Illinois before 1860 and married Jane E. who was from Gap, PA. Thank you in advance for sharing any information you have.