The results of Y-DNA show there are two families named Puterbaugh and not related at the 1700 time line. May have had a connection back thousands of years ago though.
This family is seperate from John Peter and brother or cousin George -- father Thiel Puterbaugh and started out in Md.
Seperate Puterbaugh family and can be traced by New Jersey.
George Poterbach, b ca 1757, m Elisa/Elisabetha Barbara Teel. Their sons were:
*1) George Henrich Puterbaugh, b 1777, m Effie Henry
2) Joseph Puterbaugh, b 1778, No further information
**3) Johannes Puderbaugh, b 1780, m Jane Kishpaugh
*1) George Henrich Puterbaugh, b 1777, m Effie Henry. Their children were:
A) Andrew Puterbaugh, b 1801, m Hannah Honeywell (my ancestor)
B) Joseph Puterbaugh, b 1804, m Clarra __?__
C) Elizabeth Puterbaugh, b before 1810
D) George Puterbaugh, b 1810, m Mary Case Lewis
E) Samuel Puterbaugh, b 1812, m 1) Lydia Kocher
m 2) Susan Kocher
F) John Pewterbaugh, b 1816, m Susan Miller
G) Isaac Puterbaugh, b 1822, m Elizabeth George
H) Margaret Puterbaugh, b1824, m _____ Card (?)