Thank you for the info. I'm beginning to think someones memory is a little faulty or that Rosa/Rose/Rosie is someone who ended up in the same household for some reason. I know that Rosa and my great Uncle Andy Carpenter on 18 Sept 1920 and that she was 19 when they married. So I guess that she was born about 1902. My great grandmother Minnie D. was married to Chester Ollie Carpenter, brother to Andy. She was born Sept. 25 year unknown and died in Jan of 1943. If you or anyone comes across any info on this let me know. Thanks a million.