After reviewing all of the records that I can find for any Winifred Shinn I have come to the following conclusions: There were 4 Winfield's.
#1 Winfield Shinn, b. 1864, son of Charles Henry Shinn / Mary Milsin. Married Ella Smith - Had descendants?
#2 Winfield Charles Shinn, b. <1852> Phili Pa, son of ?. Married Mary ?. Had son Winfield Charles Shinn Jr. Had other descendants.
#3 Winfield Charles Shinn Jr., b. <1875> Phili Pa, son of Winfield Charles Shinn / Mary ?. Married Effie E. Naugle. Had Winfield Raymond Shinn. Had other descnedants.
#4 Winfield Raymond Shinn, b. 1893 Phili Pa., son of Winfield Charles Shinn Jr. / Effie E. Naugle. Married Charlotte Hazel Rhone. Had descendants.
I could use help on this family as I cannot connect the descendants of Winfield Charles Shinn <1852> in the new Shinn book as I can find no parents. If anyone is descended of this family and can prove lineage or wants help proving lineage, please contact me.