If your Recompense Murphy is the son of William Murphy (1742-1830) and Phoebe Sherry (1744-1828) then we are distant cousins. I am descended from Recompense's brother Samuel Murphy (1774-1862) who moved to Franklin County, Indiana sometime between 1810 and 1828.
It looks like we do have a conflict on the birthdates of your Recompense and my Samuel (both in 1774), unless they were twins. Our family lists your Recompense as born in 1776.
I would like to compare lines with you, if you think we have a match. I have leads on nine different individuals with Recompense as first or middle names; seven of them are Murphys.