Some specific dob, dod might help.
I have an Alfred and a Horace that were brothers one generation short of your Alfred. There were born in early 1850's. I have their ancestry but haven't worked their lines forward yet. And they were in the Bridgeville area. A few years later 1860 there was born an Ambrose Willey whose wife was Annie E. LNU and who had a son named Horace.
So we have Horace H. Willey b.4/1896 (son of Ambrose), and a Horace B. Willey b. 7/1894 md to a Ruth.