Eric, I got the information about Paul Tucker's wife Sarah Westmoreland from Sherry Mideiros . She is a great-granddaughter of Caledonia F.Tucker, b. 1862, dau. of Paul and Sarah.
I've been curious about Sarah. If she were a Westmoreland, and your information from the death certificate indicates that she was, then WHO was her father?? She doesn't appear in the 1850 Independence Co., AR with the rest of Alberty Westmoreland's family. But then the 1850 isn't apparently complete because Alberty's wife and some of the children aren't listed either.
I have learned that Amanda Emaline Westmoreland, dau. of Alberty and Mary Wilson Westmoreland, married in Independence Co., AR 8 July 1852 to Isaac Robinson. Amanda died before October 1853 and there was no surviving child.
That Paul Tucker is in Yell Co., AR in the same general area as Alberty Westmoreland (Chickalah Twp) I would hazzard that Sarah Westmoreland Tucker was either his daughter or possibly his widow. However, I don't have the listing for Alberty in the 1870 Yell Co., AR census and I don't know when and where he died.
Do you know if Paul Tucker was married more than once? I ask because I can't fit Sarah into Alberty's family. She is probably a daughter, but the census records on this family are so messed up it is difficult to determine exactly how many children he did have.
Write me at firstname.lastname@example.org
and let's explore this some more. I'm very eager to determine if Sarah Westmorealnd Tucker was the daughter of Alberty and Mary Wilson Westmoreland.