As a follow-up to my original post
I have a large paper trail that assures me of my line back to abt 1723 and the John McDonald (Iain MacEoghain Oig) mentioned in the book Rawdon & Douglas.
In page 112 of Donald MacDonald's 1965 book Slaughter Under Trust, the author writes about the same family story that has been passed down in our family of an escape from Glencoe, and even uses the same family names (Ewan and Ewan Og) and saying descendents still live in Canada.
This has been an oft-printed story and many in the family have used it to reference our descent form Glencoe. But a noted Highland genealogist (Dr William Matheson) wrote a letter in 1970 that said the patrynomic "Eoghain" did not lend itself to any known Glencoe genealogies and was probably of Glenmoriston descent (Clan Eoghain Bhain). That alone led myself and another descendent researcher to question the Glencoe family origins
In Clan Donald Magazine V. 13 there is a mention of the cairn erected in Pictou Nova Scotia to my GGGG-GF Iain MacEoghain Oig, and also to my GGG-GF, his 4th and youngest son, Ewen. It is annotated with the words "Survivor of Glencoe", http://www.clandonald.org.uk/cdm13/cdm13a15.htm
I took the Clan Donald DNA test in dec 05.
My results indicate I am R1b1.
The DNA administrator has samples from several who also can claim Glencoe descent, and they are R1b's also, but it is clear I am not paternally related to them.
The administrator wrote back to me:
"I have three R1bs who can trace back to Glencoe circa 1730, one of whom descends from the Glencoe chief at the time of the 1745 who was no longer paternally Somerled. You are not close to those tightly grouped signatures. They are at least 7-8 steps from you and not paternally related to you. There is also a Somerled signature with a family story like yours of flight from Glencoe but you are not R1a and clearly not related. Yours appears to be an â€œOâ€™Neil/ Colla Uaisâ€ signature which may be either of Oâ€™Neil derivation from a variety of potential sources or a MacCarthend branch descendant of Colla Uais who may have come to Lorn with Godfrey MacFergus in 836 AD to fight Picts for Kenneth McAlpin. That doesnâ€™t disprove your Glencoe hypothesis since Iâ€™m sure there were a variety of genetic signatures in the village. It does make the Glenmoriston story more plausible."
In the book "Story and Song from Loch-Ness side (page 135) is a 1-line entry about the MacDonald's of Glenmoriston and 'Conn of a 100 Battles' from whom they descended
My family research has not located any other MacDonald families in Pictou County Nova Scotia in the 1773-1815 time frame who were related to my own MacDonaldâ€™s. Yet many in that area came from Urquhart & Glenmoriston. http://www.electricscotland.com/history/canada/pictou/pictou...
My MacDonald family was on the Ship Glasgow on 4 Sept 1775. It left from Fort William, retracing the 1773 voyage of the Ship Pearl. Many on board the Glasgow originated from Urquhart & Glenmoriston. http://www3.ns.sympatico.ca/bryanfkeddy/novascotia.html
The book Voyagers to the West by Bernard Bailyn leaves no doubt that t Ship Glasgow and my MacDonald's sailed to NY in 1775. My GGGG0GF John MacDonald (Iain MacEoghain Oig) and the passengers on the ship Glasgow had always intended to land at NY harbor and then were going to take a sloop to the area around Johnstown NY where the 1773 settlement was made by others MacDonaldâ€™s from Glenurquhart who had sailed on the ship Pearl in Sept 1773.
3 MacDonnell brothers from Glengarry had organized that Pearl voyage. Those earlier 1773 Glenurquhart settlers at the Johnstown Patent moved North into Upper Canada (Ontario) at the outbreak of the 1775 hostilities. This still leads me to believe that my MacDonald family may have had close family already in upstate NY when they departed from Scotland in 1775
If, as I believe, my line originated in Glenmoriston, the administrator has no other DNA samples of MacDonaldâ€™s who may have come from Urquhart & Glenmoriston.
There are many possibilities regarding the DNA results. I would like to encourage all Clan Donald members to participate in the Donald DNA test. It will help unravel family genealogies such as mine