Karen, I've got a cousin named Karen Cole! My grandfather gave me a Bible that had belonged to his parents. I'll list the people it has in it. We also have info on our branch of the tree if you decide we're related somehow.
Jennie B Cole born at Griffins Corners on 7/4/1871
Mary E Cole born at Griffins Corners on 7/26/1873
Jerusha Cole born at Pine Hill 3/13/1876
George Cole born in Margaretville 8/10/1880
Nettie A Cole born in Maragetville 8/16/1883
Arthur Cole (my grandfather) born at Margaretville on 6/27/1886
It also notes Thomas Cole died at Pine Hill 5/3/1876 and his wife Jerusha Cole died in Margaretville 12/14/1891 at the age of 97 yrs
Then I believe it is in my Grandmother's handwriting that says:
John Cole died 3/8/1911
Mrs. Agnes Cole, wife of John Cole died at Margaretville 4/23/25 at age 76 yrs
Hope this helps - please email me directly at YEEFER@aol.com
I live near Portlandville NY - it's about halfway between Oneonta and Cooperstown.