In the 1837 directory of Toronto, there is a Benjamin Haywood, carpenter living on Newgate Street.
I think the Haywood is supposed to be Hayward, because he appears in other records as Hayward.
If George is born in Toronto, he might have been baptized at St James. OGS has transcribed the parish register.
See the Toronto Public Library for the directories until 1900http://static.torontopubliclibrary.ca/da/pdfs/706129.pdf