Take a look at the following web site, which has info on the Calvin Stephen Ates family.
Eliza Sullivan, daughter of Thomas Sullivan and Mary Polly Workman, was the wife of Calvin Newton Ates, Sr., a son of Calvin Stephen Ates.
The web site also has photos of Eliza Sullivan and Calvin Newton Ates, Sr..
ATES FAMILY HISTORY http://www.ulm.edu/~ringo/ates/afh/ateshome.html
My wife is a descendant of Calvin Newton Ates and Eliza Sullivan Ates.