Are you in the Butler DNA study? (www.butlerdna.org
) I would be very interested in what "family group" you are in. In the study, my Butler cousin is earliest ancestor Daniel Mangrum Butler, DNA H. Daniel did go to Texas by the way as did some of his relatives in my family.
When it comes to Butlers the only sure way to find the right ones is to be able to rule out the wrong ones with DNA.