So glad you responded. I feel there is a definite connection here because of names and location in Ireland. My Cleary's are from Londonderry area, (Culmore Point -- where lighthouse is).
Actually have little on the McGeehan's other than that Elizabeth Cleary married James McGeehan. There is a website in Ireland that I can send you that has the baptisms from 1858-1901 for the Diocese of Derry of St. Patrick's Catholic Church, parish of Iskaheen and it does show a Daniel McGeehan who was married to a Ann McLaughlin and they had a child named Eliza Jane on March 17, 1867. The two McGeehan's mentioned are several named James and one Daniel. Gives births of their children and the sponsers. One sponsor is a George McGeehan.
Appreciate hearing what you have on your John McGeehan and Elsie Jewell, as it does appear that is our Elizabeth.
You can reach me at Stars4aud@aol.com