He might be buried in the Mount Pisgah United Methodist Church Cemetery. There is a couple of years difference in age but we have found that the information on tombstones don't always match some official record.
Volume 1, Page 44: Broyles, Thomas, Sep 23, 1844 - Jan 7 1923
Location: Intersection of Pisgah Road and Stephen Brooks Road. Sometimes referred as "Pisgah"; esablished 1831.
Greene County Genealogical Society, Monuments in Time: Cemetery Records of Green County, Tennessee. The Society, Greeneville, Tennessee, 2007.