Not sure if you have checked out this website for help.http://www.rootsweb.com/~onniagar/wellandhome.htm
In our database of MATTHEWS, I have a JAMES and a THOMAS as proven loyalists. James MAtthews emigrated from New Jersey to New Brunswick (Nova Scotia) Canada then to Woodhouse Twp, Norfolk Co., Ontario.
Thomas settled in Brougham, Pickering Twp, then the Co. of York.
Carl Stymiest, U.E.