Search for content in message boards

Pte W George, East Kent Regt -The Buffs

Replies: 5

Re: Pte W George, East Kent Regt -The Buffs

Posted: 22 Aug 2012 11:00PM GMT
Classification: Query
Census are full of anomalies of one sort or another that most people don’t see because they don’t have another document, like an army attestation, to contradict it; indeed I would suggest that many trees built on Ancestry aren’t even supported with primary documents, but have just been built on census and BMD Index entries. The enumerator only wrote what they heard and being human mistakes were made, even the people who were the subject of an entry didn’t always give correct information. Another possibility is the 1881 census people are different to the family you are looking at.

The 1891 census data for William fits with his record (you can obtain a copy of all 5 pages online, see http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/records/looking-for-perso... , so accepting there was no requirement to provide a birth certificate to enlist, it could be a mix up with names on the census.

You’ll have to cross-check births/baptisms (and perhaps deaths) against census for the children and if baptisms cannot be found online it will be a case of purchasing a few birth certificates to sort out parentage.

E.g. William vs Walter b 1861, the GRO Index to birth registrations gives:

GEORGE Walter James, Mar Qtr 1861; District Faversham; vol 2a, page 598

GEORGE William, Jun Qtr 1861; District Faversham; vol 2a, page 613

See if you can find a Walter George birth registration to fit his older brother, and look for candidate for the above Walter James in the 1861 & 1871 census, finally you should obtain a copy of William’s birth certificate; that should sort it out.
SubjectAuthorDate Posted
ElaineW58 18 Aug 2012 5:20PM GMT 
JeffH01 18 Aug 2012 8:57PM GMT 
ElaineW58 19 Aug 2012 10:16PM GMT 
ElaineW58 20 Aug 2012 2:27PM GMT 
JeffH01 23 Aug 2012 5:00AM GMT 
ElaineW58 25 Aug 2012 10:11AM GMT 
per page

Find a board about a specific topic