I just read your post 2 years later.
My gr gr grandfather was Isaac Goldsmith married to Sarah Van Volen, both from Holland and came to US around 1860. They loved on Dover St next door to your gr gr grandfather Nathan and Hannah. My gr gr grandfather was a Cigar maker. Possibly there is a connection here. I was interested to hear about the name of the company, as all I was told was that he owned a cigar company and they were well off with servants, which the 1870 and 1860 census also show.
It is interesting that my maiden name is also Murphy.
I would be interested in knowing if there is a connection.