Thank you for your reply. It's funny how Census birth info can hinder or make a search! On my Dad's side a great Grandmother's family in Vineland, NJ in 1900 seems to be spot on for her and her siblings. 1910 in Chicago all the dates for the same Great Grandmother, now married matched up. On my mom's side my Grandfather's Grandmother on the 1900 census is 10 years off of what was found in Ireland. Anna's husband consistently put 1869- 1870 for his birth, it was 1867. I have been including late month births of the previous month and early births in the next, keeping the years from 1870-1873. I don't think she was that much younger than her husband.... So, am I correct you think the Annie on St. Nicholas is a better fit?
Thanks so much, Danielle