Search for content in message boards

Source Citations

Replies: 17

Re: Source Citations

Posted: 28 Nov 2012 7:32PM GMT
Classification: Query
Marco is correct regarding GEDCOM.

A SOURCE and its corresponding SOURCE_PUBLICATION_FACTS are the correct places for dates of publication of a newspaper article. From a GEDCOM view a SOURCE_CITATION is used to identify a specific place in that source.

From the standpoint of FTM the basic source entry dialog/screen has three fields 1) Publisher Name 2) Publisher Location 3) Publish Date. FTM makes a mess of the SOURCE_RECORD in the GEDCOM when you output a source made with a template by putting everything in a NOTE.

Anyway, If you are entering a publication date for a newspaper as a separate field in the AMT citation, which is ok from a data entry standpoint, when a GEDCOM is created the date along with any other "publisher information" should be formated to follow publisher citation pattern based on any one of the well known standards like "Chicago, Evidence Explained etc.

GEDCOM does not have a field for date and does not need one. The database within FTM and AMT can have separate fields this is ok as well. The only time we care about GEDCOM is if you are creating one and you must know where to put the data to make a well formed record.

The same is true for SYNC. They should have distinct fields in their DataBases and if they do not the communication protocal should know what is needed to consistantly make the date data and other data go back and forth without data loss.

This is a bug that can be fixed since the interface and products come from the same company.
SubjectAuthorDate Posted
stephenkhigha... 28 Nov 2012 7:47PM GMT 
MarcoScavo 28 Nov 2012 8:06PM GMT 
silverfox3280 28 Nov 2012 10:00PM GMT 
BurgessDonnel... 28 Nov 2012 11:54PM GMT 
silverfox3280 29 Nov 2012 12:37AM GMT 
MarcoScavo 29 Nov 2012 12:54AM GMT 
kj_norway 29 Nov 2012 2:32AM GMT 
kj_norway 29 Nov 2012 2:43AM GMT 
stephenkhigha... 29 Nov 2012 12:34AM GMT 
stephenkhigha... 29 Nov 2012 2:46AM GMT 
per page

Find a board about a specific topic