Search for content in message boards

Sourcing Relationships

Replies: 30

Re: Sourcing Relationships

Posted: 25 Feb 2013 11:36PM GMT
Classification: Query
Edited: 25 Feb 2013 11:37PM GMT
Thanks for the comments KJ. Educational as always.

However, I disagree with you on one aspect: that DNA evidence should just be "rolled into" the normal equivalence of a judgement of a relationship coming from paper records.

The reason is a basic one of human behavior. All paper records are based on facts that should not really be assumed , but are often ignored: 1) If a woman is married, she is assumed to be faithful and 2) otherwise, that she really knew who the father was, and/or accurately revealed who the real father of a child was.

Another aspect of weakness of paper records comes from often not knowing which wife of a man was the mother of a child when a man had multiple wives. That issue can also exist when a woman has multiple husbands and a child from one father takes the name of another husband.

It seems to me the "paper judgment" of: "possible" to "almost certainly" should come from paper records and they are then proved (or depending on the test, corroborated) or disproved by DNA records.
SubjectAuthorDate Posted
silverfox3280 24 Feb 2013 1:48PM GMT 
kj_norway 24 Feb 2013 2:31PM GMT 
silverfox3280 25 Feb 2013 6:37PM GMT 
kj_norway 26 Feb 2013 4:26AM GMT 
silverfox3280 26 Feb 2013 6:36AM GMT 
kj_norway 26 Feb 2013 8:37PM GMT 
silverfox3280 27 Feb 2013 3:09AM GMT 
kj_norway 27 Feb 2013 2:00PM GMT 
silverfox3280 27 Feb 2013 3:12PM GMT 
DonVarner01 25 Feb 2013 3:53AM GMT 
per page

Find a board about a specific topic